Second Life is one of the newest examples of advances in technology that change peoples lives so drastically and differently than ever before experienced that we can't quite know what the results will be. Personally I believe Second Life represents both the promise and the extreme new dangers that the connected digital world presents.
It is undisputed that the tools and environment provided by Second Life allow people to develop and show off creativity they otherwise couldn't. Those who don't have the money to create designs or connect with millions of other people now can. Most importantly they can create, copyright, and then sell. This allows untold innovation and encouragement for those who didn't have it before.
At the same time this opportunity creates dangers that many may not realize. Most importantly Second Life can eclipse and replace real life. Anyone who has ever played any online persistent games knows the pull of giving up portions of your real life to spend one more hour advancing your virtual surrogate. Eventually online friendships take present over real world friendships. Some would argue online friendships are real friendships because there are real people on the other end. For those that meet and engage in activities in real life with those people this is true and I have no problem with this but the human being needs physical interaction and shared experiences beyond those programed by the latest big name developer. But these games have been around for awhile and I think most people realize the pull of the online world and it's dangers before they've lost their real life and then work out a balance best for themselves.
Where I see the big danger in Second Life over the online games is the money and programming aspects. The danger in being able to program anything is simply that one could easily spend 1 month programming a 10 min experience to share with online friends rather than spending that month sharing days worth of real life experiences with friends. This in itself is only really a danger if money is added in the mix. Money tips the balance one finds between real and online life in online's favor. Now spending a month to make a 10 min online experience isn't just making a 10 min experience, it's that and how ever much money you can make off selling that experience to thousands of other people. Make enough money and financially it becomes more profitable to spend all your time online than in the real world. And money is one of the few things that is powerful enough to actually rope people in to giving up their real world lives.
Of course people become workaholics in the real world too for money but at least there you need to get out of your basement to make money and most often your work isn't also a medium for virtual social interaction as well. Also if you have your own business you control your own material and market. Short of a nuclear bomb your market and your means to get to them will exist. Second Life goes down and suddenly your life, socially and financially, is gone. And it's far easier for a server to go, company to go bankrupt, files to be corrupted or erased, or lawsuit to take out a virtual world than for the real world to end (in which case Second Life would go down anyway).
Sunday, September 30, 2007
Sunday, September 23, 2007
Forces of Voices
Can a big company be severely damaged and thrown into the red because of one disgruntled person?
The emerging consensus seems to be yes...if they have a blog. Two articles, one from the Financial Times and one from Business Week, give the impression that blogs will be one of the biggest factors companies will have to deal with in the future. It's even suggested that soon blogs will become as powerful or even one of the same as traditional media. However I believe blogs will face the same creditability and respect hurdles that traditional media faced and that how blogs respond to these hurtles will either keep them from being as powerful as traditional media or will make them lose the very thing that makes them unique and new.
The first hurdle I see is credibility. I think part of the reason people turn to traditional media in the first place is because they have at least an intent of being objective and to only report the truth. Blogs are still viewed by the majority of the population as opinion pieces and therefore interesting but not something to change their own opinions over. When someone searches for a blog they are often looking for topics of points of view they already agree with. If you have a problem you look for people that have the same problem or if you're against a candidate you look for blogs that are also against that candidate. If you find something you don't expect or are opposed to on a blog your first reaction is to either reject it as the ramblings of someone who doesn't know as much as you or to go to trusted sources such as traditional media to find their facts.
Contrast this to traditional media where if you read it there you automatically assume it's true and if you disagree look for evidence to disprove it. On the one hand it means that you will find less opinions in traditional media, the stories may be slower to develop, smaller issues may not come up, and stories hard to verify won't be told at all but every story that is told will carry the weight of 100 blog posts and instantly effect the thoughts of millions of people.
Blogs obviously have their own place and power but I don't think they will ever become as powerful as traditional media without becoming that very media and losing what makes blogs worth reading in the first place.
The emerging consensus seems to be yes...if they have a blog. Two articles, one from the Financial Times and one from Business Week, give the impression that blogs will be one of the biggest factors companies will have to deal with in the future. It's even suggested that soon blogs will become as powerful or even one of the same as traditional media. However I believe blogs will face the same creditability and respect hurdles that traditional media faced and that how blogs respond to these hurtles will either keep them from being as powerful as traditional media or will make them lose the very thing that makes them unique and new.
The first hurdle I see is credibility. I think part of the reason people turn to traditional media in the first place is because they have at least an intent of being objective and to only report the truth. Blogs are still viewed by the majority of the population as opinion pieces and therefore interesting but not something to change their own opinions over. When someone searches for a blog they are often looking for topics of points of view they already agree with. If you have a problem you look for people that have the same problem or if you're against a candidate you look for blogs that are also against that candidate. If you find something you don't expect or are opposed to on a blog your first reaction is to either reject it as the ramblings of someone who doesn't know as much as you or to go to trusted sources such as traditional media to find their facts.
Contrast this to traditional media where if you read it there you automatically assume it's true and if you disagree look for evidence to disprove it. On the one hand it means that you will find less opinions in traditional media, the stories may be slower to develop, smaller issues may not come up, and stories hard to verify won't be told at all but every story that is told will carry the weight of 100 blog posts and instantly effect the thoughts of millions of people.
Blogs obviously have their own place and power but I don't think they will ever become as powerful as traditional media without becoming that very media and losing what makes blogs worth reading in the first place.
Sunday, September 9, 2007
Where We Fit
Can our social interactions and networks be categorized and placed neatly in a diagram? Rob Cross, Nitin Nohria & Andrew Parker seem to think so in "Six Myths About Informal Networks — and How To Overcome Them". They discuss making diagrams of social networks and how to interpret each player in the network. The network diagrams are based on who people associate with and who they give and receive information from. While it's interesting to see who fits in where the amount of info you can gather is limited because you can't tell much about the value of a person. While someone who gives and receives a lot of information may seem like the most valuable person in the group they actually might be a drain on the system and slowing down the exchange of the very information they seem to be facilitating.
I think more valuable are the overarching conclusions you can gather about a network as opposed to looking at the individuals. Rob Cross, Jeanne Liedtka, and Leigh Weiss discuss some of the things you can infer in "A Practical Guide to Social Networks". The models of Customized, Modular, and Routine Response networks identify how a network works and what kind of problems and situations it best handles. This seems incredibly useful because you have the purpose of the network dictated by what industry it serves and you can see how well the network is structured to deal with that purpose by comparing it the general models. I work in a police setting where every problem is different and the goals change depending on the situation and our social networks are in the Customized model to deal with this. Most officers contact a lot of different other officers, supervisors, and detectives who are each know to be especially good or knowledgeable at one thing or another.
Who knows what is not nearly as important as having a network where you can find the right person to solve the problem.
I think more valuable are the overarching conclusions you can gather about a network as opposed to looking at the individuals. Rob Cross, Jeanne Liedtka, and Leigh Weiss discuss some of the things you can infer in "A Practical Guide to Social Networks". The models of Customized, Modular, and Routine Response networks identify how a network works and what kind of problems and situations it best handles. This seems incredibly useful because you have the purpose of the network dictated by what industry it serves and you can see how well the network is structured to deal with that purpose by comparing it the general models. I work in a police setting where every problem is different and the goals change depending on the situation and our social networks are in the Customized model to deal with this. Most officers contact a lot of different other officers, supervisors, and detectives who are each know to be especially good or knowledgeable at one thing or another.
Who knows what is not nearly as important as having a network where you can find the right person to solve the problem.
Sunday, September 2, 2007
Myths and People of informal business networks
Today I read two articles about using informal networks in a business from a managers stand point.
The first was "Six Myths About Informal Networks — and How To Overcome Them" by Rob Cross, Nitin Nohria & Andrew Parker. When I first started reading the myths I thought how if I was a manager I could definitely see myself thinking the same wrong things the managers in the article seemed to. The first myth that better networks are about more communication especially struck me because it seems I hear everything is about more communication now a days. I guess that was probably true several years ago but with technology developing faster than anyone can keep up it seems today the biggest problem is not communication or information but how to sort through it all and find what is actually useful. That also leads into the articles comments about having useful connections instead of just more connections.
I've never seen a network diagram before and when I first looked at it it seemed interesting but kind of gimmicky. It wasn't until I started reading the second article "Rob Cross, Nitin Nohria & Andrew Parker" by Rob Cross and Laurence Prusak that I started to see how you could actually use the diagrams. Besides seeing how useful the diagram could be It also seems weird that you can actually plot and see and paper how something so elusive and informal like who talks to who and who gives information to who. Makes me want to diagram my office and see what comes out.
The first was "Six Myths About Informal Networks — and How To Overcome Them" by Rob Cross, Nitin Nohria & Andrew Parker. When I first started reading the myths I thought how if I was a manager I could definitely see myself thinking the same wrong things the managers in the article seemed to. The first myth that better networks are about more communication especially struck me because it seems I hear everything is about more communication now a days. I guess that was probably true several years ago but with technology developing faster than anyone can keep up it seems today the biggest problem is not communication or information but how to sort through it all and find what is actually useful. That also leads into the articles comments about having useful connections instead of just more connections.
I've never seen a network diagram before and when I first looked at it it seemed interesting but kind of gimmicky. It wasn't until I started reading the second article "Rob Cross, Nitin Nohria & Andrew Parker" by Rob Cross and Laurence Prusak that I started to see how you could actually use the diagrams. Besides seeing how useful the diagram could be It also seems weird that you can actually plot and see and paper how something so elusive and informal like who talks to who and who gives information to who. Makes me want to diagram my office and see what comes out.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)