Sunday, September 23, 2007

Forces of Voices

Can a big company be severely damaged and thrown into the red because of one disgruntled person?

The emerging consensus seems to be yes...if they have a blog. Two articles, one from the Financial Times and one from Business Week, give the impression that blogs will be one of the biggest factors companies will have to deal with in the future. It's even suggested that soon blogs will become as powerful or even one of the same as traditional media. However I believe blogs will face the same creditability and respect hurdles that traditional media faced and that how blogs respond to these hurtles will either keep them from being as powerful as traditional media or will make them lose the very thing that makes them unique and new.

The first hurdle I see is credibility. I think part of the reason people turn to traditional media in the first place is because they have at least an intent of being objective and to only report the truth. Blogs are still viewed by the majority of the population as opinion pieces and therefore interesting but not something to change their own opinions over. When someone searches for a blog they are often looking for topics of points of view they already agree with. If you have a problem you look for people that have the same problem or if you're against a candidate you look for blogs that are also against that candidate. If you find something you don't expect or are opposed to on a blog your first reaction is to either reject it as the ramblings of someone who doesn't know as much as you or to go to trusted sources such as traditional media to find their facts.

Contrast this to traditional media where if you read it there you automatically assume it's true and if you disagree look for evidence to disprove it. On the one hand it means that you will find less opinions in traditional media, the stories may be slower to develop, smaller issues may not come up, and stories hard to verify won't be told at all but every story that is told will carry the weight of 100 blog posts and instantly effect the thoughts of millions of people.

Blogs obviously have their own place and power but I don't think they will ever become as powerful as traditional media without becoming that very media and losing what makes blogs worth reading in the first place.

2 comments:

Unknown said...

“reject it as the ramblings of someone who doesn't know as much as you”…I love it.. that line is worth the price of admission alone. Overall, I really agree with your post and I raised many of these same ideas in class last week. It’s like blogs have a seat at the head table, but the major networks and publications are still in the center commanding the most respect…and for good reason. I feel the thing that blogs have going is the connection between them all. For instance, you can link between posts to support someone’s points or just as easily show how you refute them. right now when you flip between NBC and ABC you don’t exactly see Brian Williams and Charles Gibson debating the stories their stations broadcast.

Murtuza said...

Completely agree with your claim that blogs will never be as powerful as the media.

Indeed Blogs can be used for researchers when they are looking to find latest news or updates. However, I feel like the biggest advantage blogs have is that they build a "community." It's a network where people can exchange ideas and opinions on a topic without having to deal with a lot of the red tape that the actual news and media go through. Therefore, the opinions on blogs are generally much more honest and truthful, and this builds the foundation of an online community

Smash