Sunday, November 25, 2007

User Generated Misunderstanding

The explosion of the internet and in particular youtube and blogs has given everyone a new phenomena to try to label, use, and most often misunderstand.

User Generated Content seems to be the most promising and different thing the internet has brought about so far. Because of this it seems everyone is trying to figure out how to use user generated content to their advantage. The most obvious example are the current political campaigns. They have created youtube video's, sponsored fan made ads, and taken questions for the internet public. Yet by doing this most candidates destroy the very thing that makes internet content so powerful, the fact that it is uncontrolled. People feel they can make, do, or say anything they want and when you start trying to control the message, release videos with scripts, and screen what content you take you destroy the integrity of the user's input and might as well just use traditional methods.

Some people do understand that user generated content must at least somewhat uncontrolled but miss that a key component to internet success is the power it gives to the viewer. Youtube is great not only because it allows anyone to share video but also because it allows anyone to choose what they wish to view. If you are interested in a certain topic you can search youtube or the net for that topic and filter out anything your not interested in. It is this feature that Al Gore's new user generated channel Current TV is missing. While having random quality reports from users play preserves the integrity of the user generated content not allowing the user to somehow control what is watched means that the channel will always be behind the internet. If the all the video's are from the internet and you can only sort them on the internet then there is no reason to watch TV. We have seen this with the rise in internet television and youtube viewers and the decline of traditional TV viewers. Unless TV can offer something the internet cannot, like exclusive programing or first access the channel will not sustain an audience.

But it is not only those outside the internet community that are misunderstanding the point of user generated content. Many inside the community have tried to equate user generated content with traditional forms of media. Derek Powazek wrote in 2006 that we should stop using the term user generated content and instead call things reviews or as a whole authentic media. I don't believe that traditional media such as reviews or movie or what ever non-authentic media is have anything to do with user generated content. When someone is writing on amazon they are trying to offer their thoughts on the book from their perspective. When the New York Times writes a book review they are looking at the structure, style, and other aspects of the book that may apply universally to the public. While they are similar I don't see how one could expect them to be the same and thus be insulted when one is referred to differently. One is edited, changed, and look at by many different people before it is published while the other is not. Nether is better than the other but they are not the same. And for that matter why should one care what their content is called. A video is a video and will be the same content whether you call it a movie, short, youtube video, or user generated content.

No comments:

Smash