Can our social interactions and networks be categorized and placed neatly in a diagram? Rob Cross, Nitin Nohria & Andrew Parker seem to think so in "Six Myths About Informal Networks — and How To Overcome Them". They discuss making diagrams of social networks and how to interpret each player in the network. The network diagrams are based on who people associate with and who they give and receive information from. While it's interesting to see who fits in where the amount of info you can gather is limited because you can't tell much about the value of a person. While someone who gives and receives a lot of information may seem like the most valuable person in the group they actually might be a drain on the system and slowing down the exchange of the very information they seem to be facilitating.
I think more valuable are the overarching conclusions you can gather about a network as opposed to looking at the individuals. Rob Cross, Jeanne Liedtka, and Leigh Weiss discuss some of the things you can infer in "A Practical Guide to Social Networks". The models of Customized, Modular, and Routine Response networks identify how a network works and what kind of problems and situations it best handles. This seems incredibly useful because you have the purpose of the network dictated by what industry it serves and you can see how well the network is structured to deal with that purpose by comparing it the general models. I work in a police setting where every problem is different and the goals change depending on the situation and our social networks are in the Customized model to deal with this. Most officers contact a lot of different other officers, supervisors, and detectives who are each know to be especially good or knowledgeable at one thing or another.
Who knows what is not nearly as important as having a network where you can find the right person to solve the problem.
Sunday, September 9, 2007
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
3 comments:
I agree with your observation that an individual that may seem like a valuable person in the group as they may be giving and receiving a lot of information, however in actuality, they could potentially be a drain on the system and slowing down the exchange of information.
This observation brings about several questions, regarding one's role in an organization. If you are in an organization, are you supposed to help people by providing them with relevant information, even if you might be slowing down the process of information flow, or else how is one supposed to do it?
Your experience in which the police use different people for constantly changing situations is interesting. I suppose it's wrong for us to assume that every network is constant. All those visual netowrks we look at so often are hardly stagnant. Good point!
I think you should always give out as much information as you can if you have time. If you are creating a bottleneck then it is up to your supervisors to make structural changes to fix the bottleneck and make it so less people are coming to you for information. In the end the structure should inherently efficient and shouldn't need conscious decisions from it's players to keep it efficient.
Post a Comment